Writing the Review Report

A review is only as useful as its report. The enemy is noise: a report padded with trivial or low-confidence findings buries the defects that matter.

Executive Summary

• report-executive-summary: The report MUST open with a 2-4 sentence executive summary stating the overall verdict and the most important findings.

Per-Issue Entries

• report-issue-entry: Each issue entry MUST name the file:line, the concrete failure scenario (inputs/state to wrong output), and a one-line fix.

Precision Over Volume

• report-precision-over-volume: The report MUST prefer precision over volume — roughly 80% noise is the enemy; a missed real defect is worse than a dropped trivial one, so low-confidence findings are summarized, not belabored.